Niblets for 5/9/09

Tags: , , , , ,


By Bill Smith

Best Email of the week:

Comment from Alex on “Anatomy of a blown draft—Browns and Raiders”:

you are completely wrong about the browns draft. i’m not even of fan of theirs but can you really not understand what they were trying to do? the team is in rebuilding mode because their last coach and GM had a terrible roster. they trade down and add depth. you know who did that? the patriots as soon as belicheck took over. the browns got players that are familiar with mangini’s system and added a bunch of depth. the draft value chart is a guide and not a strict rulebook. many people have even argued that those figures are out of date based on when it originated and how the cba has changed. in conclusion, you’re a dumba**

This was just one of a number of rather less than complementary comments I received about that column. First of all, I agree that the Browns were smart to trade down. However, they did not get anything close to market value. I am not the only one to say that. For example, several teams traded down a couple of spots in the second round and got a 4th round pick in the deal. The Browns traded down in the first round and got only a 6th. The value chart is used by almost every team. While each deal is different the Browns got less than 70% of the value of the pick trading from 5 to 17.

Mangini likes guys he knows. That is clear from the fact that the Browns second color is now Green rather than Orange. However, the 3 players that the Browns got were not in the starting plans of the Jets. What the Browns got were 2 free agent fill in starters from last year’s Jets D that gave up more points than Cleveland’s did.

QB Brett Ratliff will be a clip board jockey 3rd or 4th string QB that can maybe run the scout team. He has some upside and might someday be a starter.

DE Kenyon Coleman came to the Jets as a Cowboy reject in 07. In his last 32 games, he has a total of 2 sacks and what is worse—he is 30 years old. He is not the pass rusher the Browns needed.

S Abram Elam was a restricted FA this off season and someone that Mangini wanted. The Browns made an offer but the Jets matched it. Elam was not going to start for the Jets. In the last two seasons he has played in 29 games and has one—that’s right 1 single interception. He will be 28 half way through the season.

I stand on my original position and Alex, learn to use the shift key. I love the passion but it makes your email hard to read.

NOTE: This article did get picked up by more than a dozen web sites.

Updates on previous columns:

Brett Favre is messing with his legacy. ESPN and Sporting News Radio are all Favre all the time. Farve said that he is definitely retired and has no intention of playing now. That was just before he sent his X-rays to the Vikings. Take it any way you want but Favre loves the attention.

The Commissioner suspends the entire National League for 50 Games! Since some of the names on the 2003 list were leaked, Baseball owes it to the fans to release the other names or fire anyone that was involved in the leak. If they have problems finding out who it was, fire everyone in the league office that was involved. That would send a message to the rest of those pinheads that leaking confidential info is not to be tolerated.

Niblets fresh from the Cob:

Former Bills QB Jack Kemp passed away. Kemp was a guy that used every ounce of his talent and energy in everything he did. After football he was a Congressman from NY and a candidate for VP. Players today could use some of his dedication to the game. He gave it everything he had every day.

Former NBA and Olympic coach Chuck Daly passes away. When you think of an NBA team playing like a unit, Daly’s teams are among the first that come to mind. In the hardest sport to coach because of guaranteed contracts and a bench full of head cases, Daly got the best out of any team he coached. The teams seemed to take on his character—tough, physical, and disciplined. He will be missed.

The NCAA is looking at changing the charging/blocking rule in college basketball. Having refed an industrial league with some pro rookies, I can tell you that the charge/block is the toughest call there is. Mike DeCourcy of Sporting News Today reports the rule committee has recommended a change so that a secondary defender must not be under the basket and must make an attempt to defend the basket to get the call. Otherwise it is a blocking foul. That is a good change. The committee looked at the issue of a player unable to take a foul shot but decided not to propose a change at this point.

The worst thing that can happen to a manager is to win the Manager of the Year award. The Diamondbacks fired Manager Bob Melvin yesterday. The team was 8.5 games behind the Dodgers before last nights game. Melvin had won the MOY award in 2007 and now his history. Winning that award is almost as deadly to a career as the owner making a public statement of support.

That’s what I think. Tell me what you think.

Bill Smith is a former coach of several semi-pro teams, has officiated both football and basketball, done color on radio for college football and basketball and has scouted talent. He is a senior writer for and edits He has also published several novels on and edits .

My email is [email protected]

Technorati Tags: Favre,steroids,Kemp,Daly,Sporting News Today,Diamondbacks,Manager of the Year,Melvin,NFL Draft,NFL,Browns,Raiders
Niblets for 5/9/09 by
No votes yet.
Please wait...

Tags: , , , , ,

2 Responses to “Niblets for 5/9/09”

  1. Free T Shirts
    on May 12th, 2009
    @ 1:31 pm

    Use the shift key, killing me.
    I understand that you like the value chart but from a fan’s perspective, it looked like a decent draft. Comparing to the Raiders is odd.

    No votes yet.
    Please wait...

  2. Houston Astros tickets
    on Jun 3rd, 2009
    @ 7:35 pm

    Nice blog, contains niblets of all sports! I like it!

    No votes yet.
    Please wait...

© 2020 FryingPanSports. All Rights Reserved.

This blog is powered by the Wordpress platform and beach rentals.