The NFL got started this past weekend and here are my NFC west starting position grades.

Cardinals | |
QB | Sam Bradford or Josh Rosen |
Bradford is a victim of bad coaching and being put in too soon after an injury. Rosen is green as baby peas. C+ | |
RB | David Johnson |
He is solid IF he can stay healthy. Some decent depth behind him. B | |
WR | Larry Fitzgerald & Christian Kirk |
Fitz is older than rock and Kirk is a rookie. Behind them group includes Browns reject Greg Little. C- | |
TE | Jermaine Gresham & Ricky Seals-Jones |
Solid group here. Both can run and catch. B | |
OL | lt D.J. Humphries lg Mike Iupati c Mason Cole rg Justin Pugh rt Andre Smith |
The OL has been rebuilt again. This time it seems better. B | |
DL | le Robert Nkemdiche nt Corey Peters re Olsen Pierre |
This group has yet to prove they can play. D | |
LB | solb Chandler Jones lilb Josh Bynes rilb Deone Bucannon wolb Markus Golden |
Jones is all pro and outstanding. Rest are unproven and little to back them up. C- | |
DB | lc Patrick Peterson rc Jamar Taylor fs Antoine Bethea ss Budda Baker |
Peterson has lost a step. Any group that includes a former Brown can’t be good. C | |
Rams | |
QB | Jared Goff |
Goff was good last year but bad in yr 1. I am guessing he will be OK in 18. B- | |
RB | Todd Gurley |
Gurley has 2 good seasons sandwiched around 1 bad yr. No depth here at all. B+ | |
WR | Brandin Cooks & Robert Woods & Cooper Kupp |
All three are in top 35 of the league. A- | |
TE | Tyler Higbee |
Decent guy and some depth with Gerald Everett B- | |
OL | lt Andrew Whitworth lg Rodger Saffold c John Sullivan rg Austin Blythe rt Rob Havenstein |
Solid group but a little old. B | |
DL | le Ndamukong Suh nt Michael Brockers re Ethan Westbrooks |
Huge piece of the DL missing in Aaron Donald. He is holding out for a new deal. C without him A- WITH HIM | |
LB | lolb Matt Longacre ilb Mark Barron ilb Cory Littleton rolb Samson Ebukam |
LR couldn’t figure out how to use Quinn and that hurts this group. C- | |
DB | lc Marcus Peters rc Aqib Talib fs LaMarcus Joyner ss John Johnson |
Peters has a lot to prove. Talib has lost a step. Joyner is on Franchise tag, B- | |
|
|
49ERS | |
QB | Jimmy Garoppolo |
He gave SF 5 wins to end the season. Could there be more this year? B | |
RB | Jerick McKinnon |
He came from MN and was good there. Not much of an OL here. C | |
WR | Marquise Goodwin & Pierre Garcon |
Goodwin is fine Garcon is average. Some depth B- | |
TE | George Kittle |
Kittle turned into a very solid TE as a rookie. C+ | |
OL | lt Joe Staley lg Jonathan Cooper c Weston Richburg rg Laken Tomlinson rt Mike McGlinchey |
Rebuilt OL will be better with lg Cooper & c Richburg but not sure McGlinchey can play T. B- | |
DL | le Arik Armstead lt Earl Mitchell rt DeForest Buckner re Solomon Thomas |
Thomas and Buckner are OK Rest need a LOT of work. C- | |
LB | solb Eli Harold mlb Korey Toomer wolb Malcolm Smith |
When mlb Reuben Foster gets off his 2 game suspension this group will be better. Smith helps. D+ | |
DB | lc Richard Sherman rc Ahkello Witherspoon fs Adrian Colbert ss Jaquiski Tartt |
If Sherman is healthy this group will be improved. If not group is below average. C- | |
Seahawks | |
QB | Russell Wilson |
He does more with less than any QB in recent memory. No OL, NO RUN GAME. A | |
RB | Chris Carson or Rashaad Penny |
Penny is a rookie. Carson played OK last year. C | |
WR | Doug Baldwin & Tyler Lockett & Jaron Brown |
Baldwin is solid. Rest are good. Not much depth except Marshall. B | |
TE | Ed Dickson |
FA from CR but can’t replace Jimmy Graham C- | |
OL | lt Duane Brown lg Ethan Pocic c Justin Britt rg D.J. Fluker rt Jamarco Jones |
OL got better with Brown but is not good yet D- | |
DL | le Dion Jordan lt Jarran Reed rt Nazair Jones re Frank Clark |
Clark is the only pass rusher here D- | |
LB | solb Barkevious Mingo mlb Bobby Wagner wolb K.J. Wright |
any LB group that has Mingo is bad. Wagner is fine, C- | |
DB | lc Justin Coleman rc Shaquill Griffin fs Tedric Thompson ss Bradley McDougald |
Legion of Boom is dead. 3 of the 4 are gone & SE needs to sign Thomas D | |
Discover more from FryingPanSports
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.